Comparing AWS Glue, AWS Data Pipeline and AWS Step Functions for Data Workflows

Overview

Automating and managing data workflows is crucial for business efficiency in today’s data-driven world. AWS offers several powerful tools to streamline these processes, but choosing the right service can be challenging. Each AWS Glue, AWS Data Pipeline, and AWS Step Functions service has unique features designed for specific use cases. Understanding their capabilities, strengths, and limitations will help you make an informed decision. This blog will provide a clear comparison of these three services, guiding you to choose the best option for your data workflow needs, whether you are dealing with ETL processes, data movement, or orchestrating complex workflows across AWS services.

Pioneers in Cloud Consulting & Migration Services

Reduced infrastructural costs
Accelerated application deployment

Get Started

Introduction

AWS provides multiple services to help businesses automate data workflows efficiently. AWS Glue is a fully managed extract, transform, and load (ETL) service designed to prepare and transform data for analytics.

AWS Data Pipeline is an orchestration service that automates data movement between AWS and on-premises sources.

AWS Step Functions is a serverless workflow service that helps build complex applications by coordinating AWS services.

While all three services assist in data processing, their use cases vary significantly. Understanding these differences is essential for selecting the right service.

AWS Glue

AWS Glue is a fully managed ETL (Extract, Transform, Load) service for data integration, preparation, and transformation. It allows businesses to process large-scale datasets using Apache Spark and Python-based transformations.

Key Features:

Serverless: No need to provision or manage infrastructure.
Built-in Data Catalog: Automatically discovers and catalogs data from various sources.
Job Scheduling: Automates ETL job execution with triggers and schedules.
Supports Various Data Sources: Works with Amazon S3, Amazon RDS, Amazon Redshift, and more.

Use Cases:

Cleaning and preparing raw data for analytics and machine learning.
Consolidating data from multiple sources into a data lake.
Running large-scale transformations without managing infrastructure.
For example, a retail company uses AWS Glue to extract sales data from Amazon S3, transform it to calculate daily revenue and load the results into Amazon Redshift for business intelligence reporting.

When to Use AWS Glue:

You need a managed ETL service without infrastructure management.
You are working with big data and require scalable data transformation.
You want built-in data cataloging and schema inference.

AWS Data Pipeline

AWS Data Pipeline is an orchestration service that automates data movement between different storage and processing services within AWS or between AWS and on-premises environments.

Key Features:

Data Movement Automation: Transfers data between AWS services like Amazon S3, Amazon RDS, Amazon DynamoDB, and Amazon Redshift.
Customizable Scheduling: Supports pre-defined or custom scheduling of workflows.
Fault-Tolerant Processing: Built-in error handling and retry mechanisms.
Supports Amazon EC2 and Amazon EMR: Amazon EC2 instances or Amazon EMR clusters can be launched to process data.

Use Cases:

Copying and transforming data between AWS storage solutions.
Scheduling periodic data transfers between AWS and on-premises.
Running ETL workflows with external dependencies.
For example, A healthcare provider uses AWS Data Pipeline to regularly transfer patient records from an on-premises database to Amazon S3, ensuring backup and compliance with regulatory requirements.

When to Use AWS Data Pipeline:

You need to move and process data across AWS and external environments.
You require scheduled workflows with dependencies between tasks.
You prefer a cost-effective solution for simple ETL workflows.

AWS Step Functions

AWS Step Functions is a serverless workflow service that enables the orchestration of AWS services in a stateful, visual, and event-driven manner. It is ideal for building and managing complex workflows.

Key Features:

Event-Driven Execution: Automates workflows based on triggers and state transitions.
Integration with AWS Services: Works seamlessly with AWS Lambda, AWS Glue, Amazon DynamoDB, and more.
Error Handling and Retry Policies: Ensures workflow reliability and fault tolerance.
Visual Workflow Editor: Provides a graphical interface for designing workflows.

Use Cases:

Orchestrating microservices and serverless applications.
Coordinating multi-step data processing workflows.
Automating application workflows, such as approval processes and data validation.
For example, an e-commerce platform uses AWS Step Functions to automate order processing by coordinating AWS Lambda for payment validation, inventory checks, and shipment initiation.

When to Use AWS Step Functions:

You need to orchestrate multiple AWS services into a workflow.
You want serverless automation without managing infrastructure.
You require event-driven execution and error-handling mechanisms.

Comparison Table: AWS Glue vs. AWS Data Pipeline vs. AWS Step Functions

table

glue

Choosing the Right Service for Your Needs

Choose AWS Glue if:
1. You need a managed ETL solution for large-scale data processing.
2. Your focus is on data preparation, transformation, and integration.
3. You require a built-in data catalog for schema discovery.
Choose AWS Data Pipeline if:
1. You need to move and process data across AWS and external sources.
2. Your workflow depends on periodic scheduling and batch processing.
3. You prefer a cost-effective ETL automation tool.
Choose AWS Step Functions if:
1. You need to orchestrate multiple AWS services into a workflow.
2. Your workflow requires event-driven execution.
3. You want a visual interface for workflow design and monitoring.

Conclusion

AWS Glue, AWS Data Pipeline, and AWS Step Functions serve distinct data processing and workflow automation purposes.

AWS Glue is ideal for big data ETL, AWS Data Pipeline is suitable for automating data movement, and AWS Step Functions executes workflows across AWS services.

Understanding their differences will help you choose the right tool for your specific data processing needs, optimizing efficiency and cost-effectiveness.

Drop a query if you have any questions regarding AWS Glue, AWS Data Pipeline, or AWS Step Functions and we will get back to you quickly.

Empowering organizations to become ‘data driven’ enterprises with our Cloud experts.

Reduced infrastructure costs
Timely data-driven decisions

Get Started

About CloudThat

CloudThat is a leading provider of Cloud Training and Consulting services with a global presence in India, the USA, Asia, Europe, and Africa. Specializing in AWS, Microsoft Azure, GCP, VMware, Databricks, and more, the company serves mid-market and enterprise clients, offering comprehensive expertise in Cloud Migration, Data Platforms, DevOps, IoT, AI/ML, and more.

FAQs

1. Which AWS service is best for ETL workflows

ANS: – AWS Glue is the best option for ETL workflows as it is fully managed and optimized for large-scale data transformation.

2. Can AWS Step Functions replace AWS Data Pipeline?

ANS: – AWS Step Functions can replace AWS Data Pipeline for some orchestration use cases, but AWS Data Pipeline is still better suited for scheduled data transfers between AWS services.

WRITTEN BY Aritra Das

Aritra Das works as a Research Associate at CloudThat. He is highly skilled in the backend and has good practical knowledge of various skills like Python, Java, Azure Services, and AWS Services. Aritra is trying to improve his technical skills and his passion for learning more about his existing skills and is also passionate about AI and Machine Learning. Aritra is very interested in sharing his knowledge with others to improve their skills.