Choosing Between Private Service Connect and Private Service Access in GCP

Overview

Understanding their differences is crucial for designing an optimal network architecture.

This blog delves into the concepts, architectures, and key differences between Private Service Connect and Private Service Access, providing a comprehensive comparison to help you choose the right solution for your requirements.

Private Service Connect

Private Service Connect enables private and secure access to Google Cloud services and third-party SaaS applications over a private network. With Private Service Connect, traffic never traverses the public internet, improving security and performance. This service allows organizations to create endpoints within their Virtual Private Cloud (VPC) and privately connect to services like Cloud SQL, BigQuery, or services hosted by SaaS providers.

Key Features:

• Private Endpoints: Allows the creation of private endpoints within a VPC to connect with specific Google or third-party services.
• Reduced Latency: Since traffic remains within Google’s network, it ensures low latency and high throughput.
• Simplified Management: Simplifies the process of accessing services without complex configurations like firewall rules or NAT.

Fig. 1 – Private Service Connect | VPC | Google Cloud

Example Use Case:

A company using a SaaS application hosted on Google Cloud can securely connect to the application using Private Service Connect. The connection is private, avoiding exposure to the public internet and ensuring that sensitive data remains secure.

Private Service Access

Private Service Access enables private IPs to connect your VPC to Google Cloud-managed services, such as Cloud SQL or AI Platform. This feature ensures that your services have seamless and private communication while remaining isolated from the public internet.

Key Features:

• Private IP Allocation: Allocates private IP ranges for services within your VPC.
• VPC Peering: Leverages VPC network peering to establish private connections.
• Simplified Routing: Eliminates the need for external IPs or routes for service communication.

Example Use Case:

A company deploying a Cloud SQL instance can assign it a private IP address, allowing its internal applications to connect to it directly over the private network, reducing the risk of exposure to external threats.

When to Use Private Service Connect?

1. Third-Party SaaS Integration: If you need secure and private connections to SaaS providers hosted on Google Cloud.
2. Enhanced Security for External Services: Avoiding public internet traffic is a priority when connecting to external services.
3. Centralized Management: If you want a simplified way to manage multiple connections through private endpoints.

Fig. 2 – Private service connect connection

When to Use Private Service Access?

1. Managed Google Services: If your application heavily relies on Google-managed services like Cloud SQL, BigQuery, or Pub/Sub.
2. Private IP Connectivity: Private IPs are essential for regulatory compliance or security policies.
3. Inter-VPC Communication: If your architecture involves multiple VPCs communicating with managed services using private IPs.

Architecture Comparison

Private Service Connect:

1. Service Endpoint Creation: A private endpoint is created in the consumer’s VPC.
2. Traffic Flow: Requests from the consumer’s network are routed directly to the service provider through the private endpoint.
3. Isolation: Ensures complete isolation of traffic from the public internet.

Private Service Access:

1. Private IP Assignment: Services like Cloud SQL are assigned private IPs within the consumer’s allocated range.
2. Traffic Flow: Communication occurs over VPC peering, ensuring a private and secure pathway.
3. Configuration: Involves setting up private DNS and route configuration.

Key Considerations When Choosing

1. Service Type:

• Use Private Service Connect for third-party services or simplified private connections to external services.
• Use Private Service Access to connect to Google-managed services using private IPs.

2. Complexity and Maintenance:

• Private Service Connect requires minimal configuration and is easier to manage.
• Private Service Access involves configuring VPC peering and IP ranges, which may require more effort to maintain.

3. Security Requirements:

• Both solutions ensure high levels of security by keeping traffic off the public internet, but Private Service Connect adds additional flexibility for external services.

4. Cost Implications:

• Assess the cost of setting up and maintaining each solution based on your architecture and expected traffic patterns.

Conclusion

Private Service Connect and Private Service Access are powerful tools for securing and optimizing network traffic in Google Cloud. While they aim to enable private and secure connections, their use cases and implementation differ significantly.

• Use Private Service Connect to connect to third-party SaaS or Google services through private endpoints.
• Opt for Private Service Access when you need private IPs to manage Google services within your VPC.

By understanding these differences, you can design a GCP architecture that meets your business’s security, performance, and scalability requirements.

Drop a query if you have any questions regarding these GCP architecture and we will get back to you quickly.

About CloudThat

CloudThat is a leading provider of Cloud Training and Consulting services with a global presence in India, the USA, Asia, Europe, and Africa. Specializing in AWS, Microsoft Azure, GCP, VMware, Databricks, and more, the company serves mid-market and enterprise clients, offering comprehensive expertise in Cloud Migration, Data Platforms, DevOps, IoT, AI/ML, and more.

CloudThat is the first Indian Company to win the prestigious Microsoft Partner 2024 Award and is recognized as a top-tier partner with AWS and Microsoft, including the prestigious ‘Think Big’ partner award from AWS and the Microsoft Superstars FY 2023 award in Asia & India. Having trained 650k+ professionals in 500+ cloud certifications and completed 300+ consulting projects globally, CloudThat is an official AWS Advanced Consulting Partner, Microsoft Gold Partner, AWS Training Partner, AWS Migration Partner, AWS Data and Analytics Partner, AWS DevOps Competency Partner, AWS GenAI Competency Partner, Amazon QuickSight Service Delivery Partner, Amazon EKS Service Delivery Partner,  AWS Microsoft Workload Partners, Amazon EC2 Service Delivery Partner, Amazon ECS Service Delivery Partner, AWS Glue Service Delivery Partner, Amazon Redshift Service Delivery Partner, AWS Control Tower Service Delivery Partner, AWS WAF Service Delivery Partner, Amazon CloudFront, Amazon OpenSearch, AWS DMS and many more.